Recent entries

    General Reddit 2019 ()
    #1802 Copy

    Brick_Ninja

    The big question is LEGO building considered a Masculine Art or a Feminine Art? Seems like it would be feminine, but it would be extremely hard to do with one hand covered.

    Brandon Sanderson

    It would be feminine, but that WOULD be a problem! So they might have some healthy discussion on it. I suspect that the traditionalists would land on it being a feminine art, but covertly acknowledge that most would be built with two hands, then displayed.

    The whole "one handed" thing breaks down quickly when poked with too many actual logical points. Like a lot of real-world sexism.

    General Reddit 2019 ()
    #1803 Copy

    big12griff

    I want a book published of Shallan's illustrations,that would be so awesome.

    Ben McSweeney

    A collected art book is most likely to happen in the 5-6 gap. Ideally it would showcase every artist and each illustration, plus our many alternate covers, which by then should be well over 100 pieces.

    If there isn’t space in that book for the digital ton of ancillary sketches and anecdotes about the work that I’ve been collecting over the past decade, maybe there’ll be a Shallan-focused art book down the line (well, really it would just be a me-focused book, but that amounts to largely the same thing plus extras).

    TL,DR: 4-5 years.

    ICon 2019 ()
    #1805 Copy

    Avivsm

    Stormlight is very similar to Atium. Are they belong to the same category, like Investiture manifested near a Shardpool?

    Brandon Sanderson

    Yes, they belong to the same category for sure.

    ICon 2019 ()
    #1806 Copy

    Avivsm

    The Lord Ruler write in metal important stuff. Should we need similar protections on "The Diagram" the book? Against Shardic alterations.

    Brandon Sanderson

    No for a very distinct reason and I will get into it eventually

    General Reddit 2018 ()
    #1807 Copy

    Aurora_Fatalis

    You were the illustrator for Shallan's sketches of Shardblades, right? If so, huge props for Sunraiser - it's so interesting that you chose such an iconic and historically accurate design, yet still managed to ornament it in a believable Shardblade style. I'd definitely buy one for HEMA if replicas existed, which is something I wouldn't say for most fantasy swords.

    For those of us who know what that style was used for, it has some odd implications - like the fact that someone at some point was halfswording with a Shardblade, and seeing fantasy authors acknowledge halfswording always makes me geek out! Was this design a specific order from Brandon or were you just tasked with making a more knightly sword for the king and did your own research?

    Ben McSweeney

    So, there's a few different things going on here.

    One is that, way early into the project, I did a bunch of silhouette studies for Brandon so that we could zero in on just how nutty he wanted Blades to be. From those studies he's picked out a few that we referred to when drawing the Blades in Oathbringer, and one of those in particular became Sunraiser.

    He did specify that he wanted Sunraiser to be simple and traditional and purposefully in contrast with other Blades. The long ricasso wasn't a call for half-swording in particular, but that doesn't preclude the use of that technique, and it's likely that the original spren that became Sunraiser was probably used by a Radiant with some experience in wielding oversized two-handed blades.

    From a Watsonian perspective, it's worth remembering that Shardblades are impractical interpretations of practical tools. Spren made themselves into what they thought swords were, but because of their nature the result became more about the spirit or the concept of a sword than about the requirements of forgery or physics or the practical needs of sticking pointy bits into other people.

    General Reddit 2018 ()
    #1808 Copy

    Ben McSweeney

    Every level [of Urithiru] is about 18 floors, internally. I think we decided each level was about 15' tall, for about 270' in height per tier, but those are loose numbers and may not precisely reflect the final dimensions.

    TheMightyBillend

    So overall it'd be roughly the same size as the Burj Khalifa right?

    Ben McSweeney

    Taller, but only by a bit (I say this because I've got a comparison shot somewhere in my internal docs and I remember it being juuuust a bit taller). And significantly wider, of course, the topmost tier is still wider than the Khalifa at its base. Even with the .7G allowance it's a wonder the whole thing doesn't collapse into itself.

    General Reddit 2019 ()
    #1809 Copy

    DreadPirateKaldona

    I hold out misguided hope we may eventually get a sequel with [Obliteration]. u/mistborn are you listening :-) ?

    Brandon Sanderson

    Listening. I'm trying to find a way to do some more Reckoners, now that the Apocalypse Guard fell apart.

    mraize7

    Does that mean that Apocalypse Guard will not be done? The last news was that you would do it with Dan Wells!!

    Brandon Sanderson

    Dan did a pretty good revision, but at the end, he felt it was still missing something. We agreed that it might not be right to do now. Maybe someday I'll release it to fans, and see what they think the problem is.

    General Reddit 2018 ()
    #1810 Copy

    Thedingerdonger

    Elhokar's Shardblade has all ten orders.

    Ben McSweeney

    Just to stir the pot for giggles, I can confirm that Brandon specifically called for that particular detail. Hence the extra bit of the glyphs next to the Blade.

    Could not tell you why though... he never told me! :)

    Every Blade depicted in the Shallan art so far (except perhaps that cleaver-looking beast in the dueling drawing) went through multiple design passes. He definitely cares how they're depicted.

    derioderio

    Are the two Shardbearers sparring at the bottom of the page holding Mayalaran and Oathbringer?

    Ben McSweeney

    Not Oathbringer for sure, because we have a particular Oathbringer design. That chopper is of no particular provenance at this time, at least that I know of.

    Though it's not unheard of for Brandon to pick a design that I had thought of as being "throwaway" and elevate it to something significant. :)

    General Reddit 2017 ()
    #1811 Copy

    porcipotimus

    *fan art of a whitespine*

    Ben McSweeney

    Well done. I had a difficult time with the whitespine's anatomy, to the point of largely redesigning the body again just before the deadline (we wrote an article about it on Brandon's blog, I think? -EDIT- We did! ), but you've interpreted it nicely considering the limited reference.

    Missed the vestigial claws behind the primary legs though (sorry, your quality kicked my AD brain into gear :), and the skin could be bit smoother/slicker on the flanks (they get more shellie as they dry out, so maybe he's very dry).

    porcipotimus

    Oh snaps, you're right! I missed that detail :*( He did come out a bit chunkier than I think I would have liked (I imagined them looking a bit more agile and bug-like and less "tanky"/dragon-y than this) but alas I just went with it since I was having fun.

    Ben McSweeney

    The interview talks about a bunch of the design motif stuff we went through. There was an active need to step away from the chunkier arthropod/crustacean thing we had done with chasmfiends and axehounds and cremlings, and start to widen the field a little more. I think you were right to push away from being tanky-dragony. What you have here is remarkably close to some of our earlier designs.

    At the end I was thinking of the flanks being clad in a sort of sharkskin, merging with the bonier protrusions along the spine flowing just under the skin... as the creature dries out, the skin contracts and even cracks with mineral buildup, and it becomes more rocky/tanky. It needs the storms to stay active, otherwise it's inclined to go into a sort of hibernation to conserve energy unless prey comes near. I imagine as things dry out, they crawl into cracks and hollow between the stones and blend in, waiting for the next storm. Still ready to snatch up prey or even emerge to hunt when prey draws near.

    When the weather is wet, they're out and hunting all the other critters that come out to feed in the aftermath of fresh rainfall and the newly stripped, tossed landscape. Then they fill out a little and become more like sleek sharks stalking the mountains and chasms. They get shinier and smoother and more able to move quickly. That's when they become the real terror of the hills, stalking like wolves or tigers but climbing like goats.

    It's still a mishmash design, it's not really as cohesive as I would have liked. There's room for evolutionary improvement... after all there's probably always another breed. Southern Whitespines, if you will. The Great Northern Rockback Whitespine. The tiny but deadly Deep Chasm Whitespine. The sleek and slender Eastern Spinybacked Whitespine (much more needly). I'm making all of this up as I go, but that's half the secret to doing this at all :)

    Prague Signing ()
    #1812 Copy

    Brandon Sanderson

    But no I'm really excited for the Darkside stories. We've got some great ideas for those. Now I think we're going to make sure that they have a consistent artist, that's our goal. That's our big goal, consistent artist.

    Paleo

    Will you do it with Dynamite again?

    Brandon Sanderson

    We will see. Dynamite we liked as a company. The biggest thing we didn't like was the switching artists too much and so we'll go to them and say can you guarantee us a single artist and the book sold really well so I think they can afford to pay better and get somebody. Like, you know the artists were all great but it was obvious they didn't want to stay on it because it was too much work for the pay I think.

    Prague Signing ()
    #1813 Copy

    Questioner

    What's the Dark One right now... like the film?

    Brandon Sanderson

    Oh yeah Dark One is looking great. So we have the television show that they announced so I can talk about it. I didn't leak this--with Joe Michael Straczynski, right. Yeah, they already leaked that. And Joe will write the pilot of that some time this fall or this winter. But we have the graphic novel, it's going full steam ahead and then we'll be doing some audiobook versions so they'll be like the graphic novel or an audiobook and you can just kind of choose. There won't be like a traditional novel for it probably, it will be audio or.

    Questioner

    Will the story be the same?

    Brandon Sanderson

    It will be from the same outline but there might be small deviations based on how the graphic novel but we're trying to keep it close together. The television show? No idea. Alright, because we have a really great show runner involved and they know television, they might do. But the audiobook and the graphic novel, the audiobook should be prose narrative so not just the quotes, so... and this should be graphic novel, both from the same outline we'll see how it goes.

    Prague Signing ()
    #1814 Copy

    Oversleep

    Does Nazh want his knife back, the one he gave to Kelsier?

    Brandon Sanderson

    Yeah, he would want it back but it's not like the flute. It's not something that was super super important to the person who gave it away. So he would like his knife back eventually,  but you know, nothing important.

    Prague Signing ()
    #1816 Copy

    Isaac Stewart

    And I've got, we'll do two more of the fashion pieces.

    Brandon Sanderson

    Yep, we got two fashion plates in the work also. Cause I love how those looks.

    Paleo

    The Thaylen one with *inaudible* is good.

    Brandon Sanderson

    Yeah, the Thaylen one looks great.

    Isaac Stewart

    We're still deciding on what we're doing.

    Brandon Sanderson

    Yep.

    Prague Signing ()
    #1817 Copy

    Brandon Sanderson

    The next were going to have all the Spren from Shadesmar like-

    Paleo

    All the Radiant spren.

    Brandon Sanderson

    All the Radiant spren, you know well nine of the Orders we're going to get all nine in. 

    Isaac Stewart

    We're going to do yeah, we talked about the tenth. 

    Brandon Sanderson

    Yeah, we're probably not going to do the tenth.

    Isaac Stewart

    We're going to have to wait until after the book is done to decide.

    Brandon Sanderson

    But they'll be nine of them at least. They're looking very cool, I'm very pleased with how those are. They're very like these natural history illustrations and so.

    Isaac Stewart

    They do look nice.

    Prague Signing ()
    #1818 Copy

    Questioner

    The second one is Starsight and the third one will be?

    Brandon Sanderson

    Probably Nowhere is what it's called. My US publisher doesn't like that title but I do because they go to Nowhere so we'll see if they persuade me not to use the title. That's the working title right now.

    Questioner

    When will it be in the English?

    Brandon Sanderson

    Published? It's probably not for a little while because next year is Stormlight 4 and everything I have is dedicated to writing that and so I won't start Skyward 3 until January at the earliest and probably turn it in. So I would guess two years from now would be when we would see Skyward 3. It depends on whether I write that or the last Wax and Wayne book next.

    Prague Signing ()
    #1819 Copy

    Paleo

    The Dark One graphic novel is coming out I think next year sometime? Did you also... Were you also involved there or was it more...

    Isaac Stewart

    So, Dark One, we are less involved with the actual...

    Brandon Sanderson

    We're giving them a lot more freedom because it's not Cosmere which means that their interpretation of Dark One we can let a lot more things slide because there's not a continuity happening to get in that way.

    Isaac Stewart

    So... Dark One is looking fantastic. They are so far doing a really amazing job. I think people are really going to like it.

    Paleo

    Yeah, the cover already looks fantastic.

    Brandon Sanderson

    What we're trying to do is to do a graphic novel where we give people a little more freedom and so my outline is pretty solid but for art direction things go with more what you feel. They send us their impressions and we give them responses but were not being nearly as, with the Cosmere we have to try do the detailing.

    Isaac Stewart

    And if they were to send us something we didn't like we would let them know but so far they just, the art is, I love the art in it.

    Paleo

    And like I said the cover already looks pretty amazing.

    Brandon Sanderson

    The art is amazing. The interior art like, and it's really fun because I can see exactly how my outline is turning into their scenes and things in a really fun way. I'm really hopeful. I don't know whats going to happen with the television show. That's honestly more up to Joe [Joseph Michael Straczynski] then it is to me. I mean I should be there for the writing room meetings and things like that but really we're letting Joe go and...

    Paleo

    How far has it progressed since it was announced that Joe would run the show?

    Brandon Sanderson

    How's the progress? He's finishing up a pilot for something else and then he's working on this. I don't know how far... if he's gotten to our pilot yet or not. I haven't received it yet so it's not done. Yeah, that's what I heard back in September he was finishing up another pilot so sometime soon he should be working on a pilot for this.

    Prague Signing ()
    #1820 Copy

    Isaac Stewart

    We're going through and trying to fix all of those things for a later version that Dynamite will put out, just small inconsistencies. We will get rid of the boombox, we will get rid of the second IV because we got it in the first one. I don't how we missed it in the closeups. For all I know we told them to erase it, and that one they just didn't get to, so that's funny.

    Prague Signing ()
    #1822 Copy

    Paleo

    In Allomancy, bad alloys can be detrimental to you, can make you sick and stuff like that. Does it also apply in Feruchemy or generally impurities, do they apply?

    Brandon Sanderson

    Not as strongly.

    Paleo

    How would they apply? Is it more like a smaller charge or?

    Brandon Sanderson

    It would just take less of a charge. It wouldn't make you sick.

    Prague Signing ()
    #1824 Copy

    Paleo

    When you store multiple memories in a coppermind is it still technically one large coppermind or could you say it's more like a ton of "virtual" metalminds, because you're technically tapping individual ones?

    Brandon Sanderson

    More like the second. I would say that's accurate. I mean I'm not sure that really aligns one to one but it is another good model, though.

    Prague Signing ()
    #1826 Copy

    Paleo

    Then we also talked about, theorized about unkeyed metalminds - that is Identity-less ones that anybody can that has the power can tap.

    Brandon Sanderson

    Yeah.

    Paleo

    We also were wondering is it like, we compared it to cryptography and encryption, stuff like that. Is it just that like, your Identity is sort of this unique encryption key.

    Brandon Sanderson

    And you need a key to you getting it. That's a valid line of theorizing. It is not exactly but it's close enough to be a good model.

    Paleo

    And would an unkeyed metalmind theoretically be capable of storing a little more than a keyed one.

    Brandon Sanderson

    Oh, because of yeah.

    Paleo

    Because it has to... Is it inherent to the Investiture or is it like an extra bit?

    Brandon Sanderson

    I'll RAFO that, mostly because I haven't considered that yet.

    Prague Signing ()
    #1827 Copy

    Paleo

    All right, regarding the 'Wisdom Shard' again. We have one quote where Hoid... I'll just cite it: "Some men, as they age, grow wiser. I am not one of those, for wisdom and I have always been at cross-purposes." Is he referring to that Shard there... or the Vessel?

    Brandon Sanderson

    *thumbs up, grins* ... Yes.

    Prague Signing ()
    #1828 Copy

    Paleo

    We tried to develop a theory of what a metalmind actually is, and we know that splitting a metalmind can halve the charge effectively or divide the charge.

    Brandon Sanderson

    It can divide the charge although it makes it much harder to, yeah.

    Paleo

    But is it actually physical... is the charge concentrated physically at one point or is it more like a gas so it diffuses?

    Brandon Sanderson

    It diffuses.

    Prague Signing ()
    #1829 Copy

    Paleo

    Do you actually store something related to...do you store the actual attribute or do you only store like an Investiture representation of an amount...

    Brandon Sanderson

    You store the Investiture representation.

    Paleo

    So the metal is just the focus that says this will turn into this.

    Brandon Sanderson

    Yeah.

    Prague Signing ()
    #1830 Copy

    Paleo

    Then I was wondering about the Dysian Aimians or the Sleepless. Do they reproduce at all, and if so how does it work? Like is it that one... is it asexual if they do?

    Brandon Sanderson

    So they reproduce, yes. But reproduction for them has a variety of terms. They can breed specific cremlings for specific purposes over time if they want to. They can also exchange cremlings if they need to, in order to improve their genetic diversity. Creating a new one is a different experience but yes. In fact, they... I've written sections, not for the books yet but where I talk about them developing and over evolving one of their cremlings to do something new.

    Paleo

    Okay. If they do reproduce does it require two of them or is it more like they breed enough and then they split one off.

    Brandon Sanderson

    That's a RAFO for now, but the individual's consciousness is an interesting thing for them.

    Prague Signing ()
    #1832 Copy

    Paleo

    You also said... somebody asked whether there are points in Shadesmar where you could instantly travel across diametrically opposed points on a planet.

    Brandon Sanderson

    Right, there has to be.

    Paleo

    Of course, I heard topology last year in university and it's all about mappings and stuff like that and so I was wondering just how continuous - if you know math term - the mapping from like the Physical Realm to the Cognitive Realm is.

    Brandon Sanderson

    It's not very. You'll notice already elevation is not mapped, you can find points in the books already where someone appears closer to the sea level and things so it's not very... there's a lot of bending going on and it gets worse or more obvious the further the series goes. Not a one to one correlation, not even close.

    Paleo

    So it's not just that it's very compressed it actually doesn't match some things.

    Brandon Sanderson

    Yeah, no. Imagine that things in the Physical Realm are mapping to places in the Cognitive Realm but not, they're not alternate dimensions of one another that are overlapping one to one.

    Prague Signing ()
    #1833 Copy

    Paleo

    On the Discord also they tried to... because the moon is always like on the horizon and they did the math and technically it's possible but it would have to change its inclination I think through one hundred degrees every turn. Is it natural or is it also maintained by...

    Brandon Sanderson

    It is also maintained by the system. We ran the math on that one too. It, like, the Rosharans also are not in a stable orbit but this one's even less in a stable orbit, let's just say that.

    Paleo

    Somebody did like the universe simulator thing and somebody ran it to Roshar and they said it crashed into each other.

    Brandon Sanderson

    I mean they would, we find we got like ten, no like a hundred thousand years before it happens but yeah, the moons are very not stable on Roshar, let's just say that. I'm not convinced that the continent is stable either. On geological terms I don't think... if Roshar were as old as Earth is, you would not have a continent, is what I think. Even with the crem and stuff.

    Paleo

    The crem isn't enough... you said before that it shifts east?

    Brandon Sanderson

    That's what I think, I haven't done the math but that's what my instinct says that it wouldn't be enough. But we'll leave that for people who actually run the math until they... because I do not have time to get a degree in ecological science.

    Prague Signing ()
    #1835 Copy

    Paleo

    In May, in Germany, you told me that... or I asked whether Wisdom was a Shard, and you said it was or something like it, and that wisdom was close to an intent of a Shard, and you also told me that it has realized that survival isn't necessarily the most important thing for it. I wanted to ask whether it has realized that over time or was it from the get go?

    Brandon Sanderson

    Over time.

    Paleo

    Okay, so then naturally, my next question: Is it the survival Shard?

    Brandon Sanderson

    RAFO.

    Paleo

    And then somebody actually came up with another good probable name. Is Prudence close?

    Brandon Sanderson

    Prudence sounds an awful lot like a Shard name. That's some excellent theorizing there.

    Prague Signing ()
    #1836 Copy

    Paleo

    So we know that aluminum resists Investiture or blocks Investiture in some cases. Does it act like radiation protection like lead or something that actually gets deteriorated while it's resisting something or is it like, does it just interfere?

    Brandon Sanderson

    RAFO, good question.

    Prague Signing ()
    #1838 Copy

    Questioner

    Do you need to love writing to be a writer?

    Brandon Sanderson

    I think a lot of writers hate writing so I don't think it's required. I know a lot of writers who hate writing but love to have written if that makes sense. A lot of writers do love writing but a lot of writers love to have written.

    Prague Signing ()
    #1843 Copy

    Questioner

    Is Hoid real, or is he just a fantasy form.

    Brandon Sanderson

    Is Hoid real? Hoid is real in the books.

    Questioner

    In the books, yes. So the characters are not hallucinating him.

    Brandon Sanderson

    They're not hallucinating him. We're not pulling a Fight Club or anything on you.

    Prague Signing ()
    #1844 Copy

    Questioner

    I was interested if, the Wax character, if he was inspired a little by Sams Vimes by Terry Pratchett.

    Brandon Sanderson

    Yeah, absolutely. Vimes had a deep effect on me as a writer so any time I'm writing a copper you'll end up with some Vimes but I'd say Wax has a little extra Vimes, so does Dalinar, Dalinar's got a bit of Vimes in him to.

    Prague Signing ()
    #1845 Copy

    Oversleep

    Why do Fused accelerate slower than the Surgebinders?

    Brandon Sanderson

    Fused accelerate [slower than] Surgebinder's because they're expending less energy.

    Oversleep

    It doesn't have to do with the Braize gravity?

    Brandon Sanderson

    No, it does not have to do with Braize's gravity, that's a good question. That's actually a really clever way to ask.

    Oversleep

    Yeah, cause I thought the planet was smaller so.

    Brandon Sanderson

    Clever, very clever but no, it is not to do with that. You'll find other explanations but they can expend less energy, they can afford to spend less energy. They can only afford to expend a little bit of energy so that's the way to say it.

    Prague Signing ()
    #1846 Copy

    Oversleep

    Okay now I have one about Shard avatars, like Autonomy's. Is it possible for one to form without the Shard's Vessel directly making it, so independent...

    Brandon Sanderson

    Yes, it is. They would be aware of it, however. They couldn't not be aware of it, but it could arise without their direct and conscious decision to do so.

    Oversleep

    And the one on First of the Sun, is it by Autonomy's direct...

    Brandon Sanderson

    Yes, that is directly created.

    Prague Signing ()
    #1847 Copy

    Questioner

    Before the Shattering, were people already able to worldhop from Yolen to the other planets like Roshar, and so on?

    Brandon Sanderson

    It was possible, it did not happen nearly on the extent that it happens now. It's possible. I would say that, I don't know if there, yeah very very very few instances.

    Prague Signing ()
    #1848 Copy

    Questioner

    Lightweaving on Roshar, is it more of a Physical thing or Cognitive Realm thing?

    Brandon Sanderson

    Lightweaving? I would say it's a hybrid between the two.

    Questioner

    So there's a Physical effect, but also a Cognitive component to that?

    Brandon Sanderson

    Yes, and then even a little bit of a Spiritual component. Lightweaving tends to involve, I'd say it's mostly Physical. Mostly you're not changing what someone's mind is, but you're actually changing light. Mostly Physical, but Lightweaving in particular has a lot like- you'll see weird things happening with Lightweaving on occasion, that are kind of a little bit of Cognitive and Spiritual influence that's happening. So keep your eyes on that. Yeah, I would say, if you're asking is light actually being changed yes, it is.

    Prague Signing ()
    #1850 Copy

    Questioner

    So after Nightblood was used pretty obviously in Thaylen City does Zahel [or Vasher] know?

    Brandon Sanderson

    Where Nightblood is? Zahel is pretty sure where Nightblood is; Vivenna does not know. She's on the look out let's say.

    Questioner

    I guess it's hard to get back from Shadesmar.

    Brandon Sanderson

    It is. She had some plans and that didn't work out.